Marek Fabiusz Kwintylian, Institutio oratoria, księga XI 1, 1 – XI 3, 29
Loading...
Date
2012
Authors
Advisor
Editor
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Wydawnictwo Poznańskiego Towarzystwa Przyjaciół Nauk
Title alternative
Marcus Fabius Quintilianus, Institutio oratoria, book XI 1, 1 – XI 3, 29 (Introduction and translation)
Abstract
The most important thing for orator is to know which style is the best to inspire benevolence, to provide insight
and evoke emotions in a judge, keeping in mind what results we should expect to gain in various parts of the
speech. The future orator should be taught that to speak appropriately is to take into account not only what
is useful, but also what is proper. The power of memory gives us an abundance of examples, rules, opinions,
words and deeds, thus memory is accurately called the treasure of speech. Even a mediocre speech will be
more moving when succoured by the force of actio than the best speech devoid of it. Nothing can be perfect if
the gifts of nature are not supported by creative zeal.
Description
Quintilian begins the 11th Book with a remark that the orator’s task is to speak choosing the
words carefully (ut dicamus apte). He recalls Cicero believed this to be the fourth characteristic
of good style. The most important thing is to know which style is the best to inspire benevolence,
to provide insight and evoke emotions in a judge, keeping in mind what results we should expect
to gain in various parts of the speech. The whole question of language appropriateness is based
not only on the type of style, but also on rhetorical invention. The future orators should be taught
that to speak appropriately is to take into account not only what is useful, but also what is proper.
It is crucial to learn the character of an orator and the person he defends, as well as the characters
of people in front of whom we are to speak. Laudatory speeches which are composed for giving
pleasure provide much more refined and magnificent topics than counselling and judiciary
speeches which concentrate on action and rivalry. All exaggeration is improper; what is naturally
well composed loses its charm if not restricted by some measure. Following these rules is possible
due to accurate judgement based on intuition more than imposed strictures. All education is based
on memory. The power of memory gives us an abundance of examples, rules, opinions, words and
deeds, thus memory is accurately called the treasury of speech. According to Quintilian, the most
important feature of memory is practice and diligence. Most important is to rote learn large batches
and to think at length day by day. The third part of the 11th Book is filled with deliberations on
the subject of pronuntiatio. Quintilian finds the oratory delivery of a speech is often called actio.
The first term seems to come from syllabic sound, the second from gesticulation. Even a mediocre
speech, as the author of Institutio oratoria claims, will be more moving when succoured by
the force of actio than the best speech devoid of it. Demosthenes believes pronuntiatio to be not
merely first, but the one and only merit of the oratory art. Cicero also says actio is predominant in
oratory art. Yet, as Quintilian avers, there are those who believe that actio devoid of art and caused
totally by a natural impulse is more effective and is the only way of delivery behoving an orator.
These people are usually the ones who also tend to reject diligence, art, elegance of style and all
signs of enthusiasm as artificial and unnatural, or who try to imitate the old authors by choice of
words or even primitiveness of style. According to Quintilian, nothing can be perfect if the gifts of
nature are not supported by creative zeal.
Sponsor
Keywords
choosing the words carefully, type of style, rhetorical invention, memory, pronuntiatio, actio, creative zeal, gifts of nature
Citation
Symbolae Philologorum Posnaniensium, 2012, nr XXII/1, s. 89-124
ISBN
978-83-7654-082-5