The Nature of the Contract in Reasoning of Civilian Jurists
Loading...
Date
2012
Authors
Advisor
Editor
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM
Title alternative
Abstract
Roman legal texts were from the end of the 11th century until the rise of national civil codes
one of important foundations of the Civil Law Tradition. They introduced into the discourse of
jurists of continental Europe inter alia the notion natura contractus. This Latin phrase has formal
equivalents in modern civil codes, in particular in art. 1135 CC, ยง 307 BGB and art. 3531
PolKC. This formal similarity raises the question of whether the concepts represented by these
phrases are similar and if so, to what extent. The analysis of this issue allows us to identify the
common and fixed linguistic intuition of jurists, according to which nature assumes the existence
of a certain order. Since Antiquity the nature of the contract concept directed the attention
of jurists at the economic or systematic order. The first one, I mean transactions structures
covering the legitimate expectations of a party to a contract, independent from the positive law.
The second one, I mean models and classifications of contracts imposed by the positive law. Of
course, we cannot speak of any linear evolution. The recent developments in application of the
nature of the contract clause should allow for economic purposes supporting the attainment
and use of the benefit the creditor might legitimately expect upon entering into a contract.
These practice leads to greater interference with the content of an agreement than is the case
with the medieval understanding of the nature of the contract, which dominated legal discourse
for centuries , i.e. the implication of terms implied by law (so-called naturalia contractus).
In a more general dimension, my research provides historical and comparative arguments for reliance contract theory.
Description
Sponsor
Keywords
contract law, legal tradition, comparative law, freedom of contract
Citation
Dajczak, W., The Nature of the Contract in Reasoning of Civilian Jurists. Poznaล: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM, 2012.
Seria
Seria Prawo;177
ISBN
978-83-232-2474-7
ISSN
0083-4262